Florian Schneider on Fri, 28 Feb 2003 13:07:02 +0100 (CET) |
[Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]
[Nettime-bold] wsis plan of action: civil society's priorities |
[below you find the civil society action plan as it was released this morning at the prepcom2 meeting for the UN world summit on the information society. some detailled reports of what was going on here in geneva in the last two weeks you find at: http://www.worldsummit2003.de/en/nav/14.htm independently from the participation of lots of ngo's in the civil society working group preparations for various autonomous activities around the summit in the second week of december 2003 are on the way. tbc /fls] World Summit on the Information Society PrepCom-2 Geneva, February 2003 27 February 2003 23:00 WSIS- Civil Society Working Group on Content and Themes -- Drafting Committee Plan of Action: Civil society's priorities This document is a work in progress that gathers proposals drafted by the various thematic caucuses of the civil society present at Prepcom2. A - List of issues B - Objectives Benchmarks _ One Public access point to the network per village/large community in 2005. _ Access to radio sets by everyone before 2010, to be ensured by governments in cooperation with the private sector and radio broadcast coverage of all of the world's population by 2010 _ Set targets for delegations in all future conference related to ICT to include at least 30 percent women, including gender and ICT advocates C - Strategies programmes, methods for implementation The WSIS Action Plan must take into account and provide support for existing Action Plans developed by the DOT Force process and the UN ICT Task Force. 1) Information and communication infrastructure: financing and investment, affordability, development, and sustainability * An official body must be settled within the ITU in charge of proposing new mechanisms of funding adapted to a society in which international information flows are one of the main sources of growth. * As many developing countries face a drastical shortage of electricity, renewable and decentralised energy sources must be mobilised and established as a pre requisite for universal access to network infrastructures. This priority shall be pursued in reference to the Jo'burg summit on environment goals. A particular attention must be given to rural and isolated communities. * Technology systems which are appropriate to local environments to effectively bridge the digital divide, for example community radio, local newsletters, and other forms of community and non-profit media shall be privileged. * Specific support must be given to the convergence of traditional community media with other ICTs, for example through community telecentres which combine community radio with the internet. * Strong public policies should be at the heart of the information societies, although some steps towards liberalisation, privatisation and competition, and the removal of excessive levels of tariffs may play a role in ensuring connectivity. In any case the latter must not represent the only strategy. * To improve efficiency and reduce costs of use of infrastructure in developing countries, optimise connections between major information networks by creating regional PSTN exchange points and by extending the capillarity of regional infrastructures. * Coordinate intergovernmental action, with participation of civil society, to establish an international agreement for negotiating fair prices for Internet traffic that must flow through root servers in the US. * Public access points rely to a large extent on the existence of terrestrial networks, and complementarily on satellites. Consequently, it is imperative for Africa to rehabilitate and develop the existing PANAFTEL network, and where necessary, complete it with new backbones to create a wide African Interconnection Network (AIN). This network should be completed by International/Intercontinental access points to the global telecommunications network. On the other hand, remote regions which are too distant from terrestrial networks should have priority access to the satellite services, particularly the RASCOM African satellite. * Regarding IP traffic, which is rapidly growing in the short term, a " Gateway Internet Exchange " (GIX) network must be designed at the regional level as a priority, in order to keep the intra-African IP traffic within the continent, with the dual goals of fully leveraging the AIN network and of reducing the volume of international traffic. * Priority must be given to those who have no access and are excluded from the information society, especially to young people, women, the elderly and people with disabilities, taking into account their specific knowledge abilities, needs and facilitating their participation capabilities. * Ensure provision for increased access to ICTs and integration into programmes that assist with poverty alleviation and the empowerment of women and men * Equitable tariff and quota structures for telecommunication services (backbone, local access, telecommunication) should be created * Link "traditional" media and the Internet for community access to information "mixed media approach", as well as embracing and building on African traditional communication channels into the information society * Community information and communication centres are critical to ensure inclusive access to information and social services. Universal access policies shall promote the best possible level of connectivity at a reasonable cost for all under-served rural, urban, and regional areas. Technological convergence must be monitored with a view to integrating traditional and new ICTs in order to create alternative forms of access that can help narrow the digital divide. The creation and provision of low-cost access equipment and multi-purpose community access points shall be an integral part of the agenda for reducing the digital divide. * Public funding should be made available to ensure Internet access in public institutions such as schools, libraries, and community centres. * To save large investment and operation costs, a common use of infrastructure is recommended for both telecommunication and radio/TV information transport and distribution. 2) Access to information and knowledge * Compilation work done in building databases and non-creative works shall not be protected under copyright law. * The right of Internet hyperlinking, framing and mirroring shall not be restricted, under the provision that the name and URL of the original site is properly indicated and acknowledged. * Free modification and adaptation of a copyrighted web page shall be permitted for personal non-commercial use as a means of free speech. * Rules of loans existing in traditional libraries must be extended without hindrance to digital media belonging to online libraries * Use of Peer to peer technology shall be promoted to share public domain information. * Authors must be encouraged to retain ownership of their copyrights and not to automatically transfer copyrights to publishers or other intermediaries. * Non-commercial use and private copy of digital contents should be regarded and protected as fair use. * Computer software has different characteristics from other creative works in that it is functional/technical works and has no meaning as a public domain after the protection period. So, computer software should not be protected by copyright, or at least, the protection period of computer software should be shortened. * Open Source/Free Software shall be adopted by all public authorities and bodies. * Developing countries should investigate how to leverage the opportunities presented by the emergence of Open Source/Free software in the context of limited financial resources and expertise. * Change current intellectual property regimes so that all information and knowledge produced with the aid of public resources, for example the outputs of publicly funded educational and research institutions, are automatically released as open content and made available and accessible at no cost into the public domain. * Software shall not be patentable, in principle. * Business model (or method) patent should not be allowed. * A first-to-invent instead a first-to-file patent application rule shall be adopted, in order to better preserve the rights of academic scientists and low-income inventors. * The purpose of patent is to develop technology and thus to promote the quality of life such as health, etc. In line with it, national policy to limit patent holders right for public health such as compulsory licensing and parallel importation should be allowed without interference of other countries as addressed in the declaration on TRIPS agreement and public health adopted in Doha WTO ministerial conference. * Web pages of all public bodies should be fully accessible with any kind of browsers, including the free software browsers such as Mozilla. * The need for a legal protection of traditional knowledge must be implemented * Generic domain names shall not be subject, in any way, to trademarks laws. * A specific status concerning transition and developing countries shall be recognized in regards to Intellectual Property Rights. * Recognition of and support for community and non-profit media as the major platform for the public to both access and contribute to global knowledge and information must be ensured. * Public service values in the Information Society should be encouraged, including genuine public service broadcasting. State-controlled media should be transformed into editorially independent public service media organizations. * Availability of both traditional and newer technologies should be guaranteed to promote equitable access to information at all levels of the information society. * Ensure free access to all scientific and engineering data and information that are available in archives, libraries and research institutions. * Promote and guarantee access for all starting from the community level. While that access should be affordable and premised on effective use of information and communication technologies, recognition should also be made that this requires not only infrastructure and technology but also meaningful content, capacity building and an enabling environment that encompasses the needs based on gender, lack or total absence of literacy, ethno-cultural diversity and political plurality. * Information and communication technologies should foster the flow and exchange of information; maximize access and participation of remote areas and marginalized groups. * Awareness should be created among civil society at large for the need to support an independent, open-access public domain * There is a need to make provision for the appraisal and preservation of, and access to information in all its forms * Scientific information should be available or at least indexed within a multilingual context. * Encourage Open Access content models whereby the content in digital format is freely available, while paper printed versions or CD burned versions may be sold by institutional or commercial channels. * Encourage publishers to develop Open Access business models whether these models are commercial or not-for-profit. * Encourage the creation by scientists of not-for-profit Open Access Journals * Encourage existing subscription-based journals to turn to Open Access models. * Encourage authors to submit their papers to Open Access Journals. * Encourage authors to write Open Access books and multimedia material for research and education. * Encourage authors to maintain a personal web page whereby all their research findings and reports are freely available. * Recommend the creation of institutional Open Archives at the national and international level. * Recommend a program funded by the UN (or its agencies) to create a worldwide portal to Open Access journals and Open Access books. * Recommend the creation of a funding program by the UN (or its agencies) to ensure financial support to not-for-profit Open Access Journals. * Recommend a program funded by the UN (or its agencies) to create a worldwide scientific Open Archive * Recommend the creation of a funding program by the UN (or its agencies) to provide financial support to the creation and maintenance of institutional Open Access archives * Encourage the creation and maintenance of mirrors sites of Open Access contents in institutions belonging to transition countries, in order to save Internet connection costs. * Recommend a program funded by the UN or its agencies to distribute free CDs containing Open Access contents to transition countries. * Recommend that member states should adopt national legislation making it compulsory for scientists to deposit their published works in a national or a UN funded worldwide Open Access archive. * Recommend that member states should adopt national regulations making it compulsory for scientists whose research is funded by public agencies or by private foundations to publish in Open Access journals. * Recommend that databases built with the help of freely available scientific content should be also freely available to all the authors that contributed to its content. * Databases built with the help of freely available scientific content should be accessible with a reasonable fee proportionate to the average income in the customer's country. * Use of Peer to Peer technology shall be promoted to share personal scientific knowledge and preprints and reprints written by scientific authors who have waived their right to payment. * International co-operation and exchange of knowledge -- North-South, South -South, and North-North -- should be encouraged through the use of ICTs. * Promote the use of ICT as an effective tool in distributing information about, and advocating against, gender-based violence. * Prepare and disseminate accessible information that strengthens prevention programs that promotes women's health such as education and information on sexual and reproductive health issues and on sexually transmitted disease and HIV/AIDS. * Extending the rights of workers and their trade-unions to the use of the internet and intranet of companies for the purpose of communication and solidarity * Civil society is encouraged to use low-cost means (CD-roms, radio etc) to deliver information widely. * Development of an interactive knowledge-sharing platform on the WSIS must be encouraged * Large-scale translation of information essential for human development must be promoted. 3) The role of governments, the business sector and civil society in the promotion of ICTs for development Civil Society * Civil society, in particular NGOs, must work closely with communities in innovating, developing and strengthening ICT-related initiatives. * Civil society acknowledges its role as a major content provider in the information society and should, therefore, be active in the promotion of public awareness on the quality of content of information circulated. * Researchers and civil society organisations should be fully involved in the formulation and implementation of ICTs and sustainable development strategies National Government and local authorities * Public authorities must ensure that market competition is fair and that monopolies are not perpetuated in the communication sector. * While public authorities should promote and facilitate infrastructure building, provide training, and create an enabling environment for ICT to be accessible for all, they should not play the role of regulators of information flow and content. * Public authorities should prioritise and promote local ICT initiatives to service local, national and regional communities. * Governments should take account of their social responsibility and commitments to international conventions, agreements and action plans and carrying out their responsibilities. * Reaffirm the role of a more transparent, participatory, and effective democratic UN system as a truly legitimate forum for global governance. * Promote corporate or employee volunteering initiatives on ICTs for development to facilitate for the private sector to share skills, expertise and resources, in order to apply them in a constructive way in ICT for development initiatives * Developing appropriate global and regional technical standards to foster the deployment and use of ICTs by ensuring the participation of all stakeholders and raising a broad awareness of the societal and ethical implications of the introduction of such standards. * Recommit to principles of open, transparent, decentralised and accountable governance mechanisms at all levels, from the local to global, and in all spheres of society, including those related to the governance of information and communication systems. * Promote further research programs on issues related to the goals approved by the United Nations Millennium Assembly especially in the developing countries. Private Sector International institutions * Awareness of Open source/Free Software should be created, especially in the developing countries. Capacity in Open Source/Free software development should be built through the development of incubator funding, a knowledge warehouse of expertise in developing countries, development of regional and national Open Source/Free Software portals, and by ensuring that technical experts in developing countries have full opportunity to participate in the development of Open Source/Free software. These should be achieved by: urging key organs such as Africa Union, UNECA, UNDP, UNESCO, World Bank, Agence la Francophonie and NEPAD among others to support Open Source/Free Software development in Africa; leveraging various free and open source capacities and resources in Africa; urging donor governments and other institutions to consider funding open source software in their developmental activities; urging African governments to adopt Free and Open Source Software; and promoting Open Source/Free Software capacity and skill development in Africa through education with emphasis on women and youth. * International community's commitments to ICT developments assistance should not be monitored through indicators alone but should also be evaluated by civil society, governments and the private sector. * Catalyze the volunteer network built during the International Year of Volunteers 2001 (IYV 2001), with nodes in over 100 countries, to support the plan of action of the Summit 4) Capacity building: human resources development, education, and training * Integrate into science curricula the social analysis of the role and use of science and technology as well as the social-cultural and economic perspectives and demands in science and technology research and development. * Develop tools and programmes that promote lifelong learning * Create awareness on the necessity of privacy protection through educational programmes conducted by governments, international organisations and civil society. * Include in formal and informal education programmes the development of skills to access and produce knowledge, as a contribution to empowerment and participation of citizens. * Governments, inter-governmental organizations, civil society actors and other stakeholders in partnership with global, regional and national open source forums should spearhead initiatives that build skills through education and empowerment of women and youth. * Governments should work with all stakeholders to ensure that Open Source is available as a platform to engineer solutions that meet the needs of the people at affordable prices. * Build capacity for the creation of locally produced, audience sensitive content that responds to local needs. Strengthening relevant and diverse programmes focused on gender-sensitive curricula in formal and non-formal education for all and enhancing communication and media literacy for women. * Develop and provide resources for ICT skills enhancement programmes in technical colleges and in particular professional academies with full involvement of the teaching staff and directors. This action should replace commercially-based joint ventures programmes with multinational corporations that provide narrow training focussed on their company products. * Integrate into curricula at all levels of formal and informal training and educational programmes education in media and information literacy and human rights. * Develop and improve the capacities of local teacher and researchers organisations by providing ICT training facilities in teachers training and research institutions, with particular emphasis to developing countries. * Develop affordable solutions in terms of hardware and software tailored to the needs of educational levels and to local conditions while promoting the combination of various media, both traditional and new. * Raise awareness on the issue of copyright exemptions and knowledge ownership through the education and training sectors. * Support training initiatives in information management and production skills for grass roots organisations in developing countries. * Develop training programmes that enable all people, and in particular marginalised communities, to be able to utilise new models of content creation, production and dissemination through the use of ICTs. * Develop alternative incentive and rewards schemes that encourage the creation and dissemination of culturally and linguistically diverse content. * Provide children, parents and teachers with appropriate training for the use of ICTs and with access to new learning models, including distance learning, on-line textbooks, and reference materials. * Increase the resource allocation of governments to programmes targeting the elimination of illiteracy, innumeracy and other learning challenges that impede the ability of marginalised sectors of society from fully accessing information necessary for their well being. * Extend ICT services in developing countries, with particular attention to Least Developed Countries (LDC), small island nations and remote parts of all countries. These services need to prioritise the needs of traditionally marginalised groups such as women, the disabled, poor young people, Dalits, linguistics and ethnic minorities, and also people who are forciably isolated and confined, such as prisoners and prisoners of war. * Develop programmes in close consultation with Indigenous Peoples such that they are enabled in the information society and can utilise new tools, if desired, in their cultural production and community development. * Ensure that the production of international E-learning programs incorporates contents, context and visions from developing countries so as to contribute to cultural diversity. * Develop early interventions programmes in science and technology that target young girls to provide access to fair and equitable participation in ICT careers. * Promote engineering knowledge transfer towards domestic capacity building in developing countries, as well as local engineering capacities to develop local knowledge and needs. 5) Security Assessing ICT impact on privacy and other civil liberties * All international treaties and agreements should include an assessment of the implications on civil liberties and human rights such as privacy and freedom of expression. * Adoption of any security-related policy should be the result of prior multi-stakeholder consultations, including civil society and users/consumers as well as business and government. * A global investigation on the impact of ICT security policies on civil liberties and human rights should be initiated under the supervision of the UN. The assessment would cover threats to privacy, freedom of expression, freedom from surveillance, etc. A public benchmarking on the evolution of this impact would be provided by a dedicated mechanism. * An independent' mechanism such as a "Privacy Protection Committee' is necessary to supervise, monitor and arbitrate privacy infringement in the Global Information Society. * Privacy security studies should be carried on for all main new technologies emerging, such as IPV6 (Internet Protocol version 6). Their potential impact on privacy and freedom of expression for the citizen and businesses should evaluated and monitored, including their possible misuse for the restriction of civil liberties and human rights. Prevention of surveillance and censorship * International cooperation should be developed to fight all forms of the surveillance and monitoring system infringing upon the values of human rights and democracy. * (Guarantee and take appropriate action to protect the right to privacy, including freedom from surveillance and censorship by utilizing ICTs at all levels of the information society) * Workers' privacy in the workplace where ICTs are being abused for the purpose of surveillance and monitoring such as CCTV, IC Card, and Network-monitoring system, should be protected. In the case of introducing new technology or policies which might infringe the worker's privacy, agreement with workers or labor unions should be made in advance in a open and transparent manner. * No implicit or explicit delegation of judicial power should be given or imposed on Internet Services Providers ISPs (Connection, site hosting) to the effect that they have to reach a conclusion on the nature and content of any information, wherever said information is stored, however the said information is transmitted. No exemption to this rule shall be allowed, even in the case of an alleged obviousness. * The right to 'anonymity' should be protected. * Technical experts to protect against illegal monitoring of private information held by CS must be secured. Electronic ID or health cards, government databases * National compulsory projects using ICTs, such as electronic national ID card initiatives and electronic health care card initiatives, should be prudently assessed with the consideration of privacy issues and risks of government surveillance issues before the implementation. * Databases of individual information, which have been established by the governments, such as the databases of residence, health insurance, education, administration related information as well as driver's license information should be reviewed on the basis of securing human rights and democracy. * These databases should not be combined and should be managed only for its respective purpose. In particular, unique ID number of residents, which could be used to link the different databases of individuals, should not be used. Security of governmental networks * Governments should take steps to ensure that their own ICT networks are well protected against invasion through the use of free and open source software. 6) Enabling environment * Competition is only one out of many ways to drive down prices and to ensure the ongoing modernization of networks and services. Promoting Media Diversity * As ICT and media diversity is a vital factor of the information society, and a key condition for freedom of expression, there should be a variety of media sources. Therefore, concentration of media ownership has to be avoided and a legal basis as well as public funding for community and non-profit media must be provided. * The radio-electric spectrum has to be managed in the public and general interest and by independent and transparent regulatory frameworks for the equitable allocation of frequencies to a plurality of media including community media. * Public financial support, training, preferred access to licenses, frequencies and technologies to promote community-based media, including facilitating links between traditional media and new ones, and to bridge the digital divide between the have and the have-nots. * Legal frameworks for allocation of broadcast frequencies should be made fully transparent where this is not already the case. Restoring the balance in Intellectual Property * Considering the change brought by the development of the digital network on the creation and dissemination of knowledge the Intellectual Property regime should be reviewed to restore the balance between the protection and retribution of authors or creators and the widest possible dissemination of knowledge (right to participate in, enjoy and share cultural life of community, the arts and knowledge). * Exemptions for fair use of information should be harmonized and the extension of the public domain guaranteed as a mean to ensure access for all to information. Promotion of Open Source/Free Software * The development of Open Source/Free Software technologies and free/open software should be promoted as an alternative that favors innovation and the development of appropriate technologies and content. * A "Programmers Without Frontiers" initiative, focused on Open Source/Free Software as applied to development needs, should be launched and coordinated under the auspices of the UN. Internet Governance * To widen the participation of all actors in the global policy decision-making system, three types of multi-stakeholder Task Forces should be set up in consultation with ICANN, composed of representatives from civil society, the private sector and governments : ss a "Root Server Monitoring Task Force" to enhance regular communication with the "Root Server Advisory Committee" in the ICANN who is in charge of the global Root Server management; ss a "Multilingual TLD Task Force" to facilitate regular communication with IETF, IAB, Root Server Advisory Committee and other grass-roots efforts, MINC, AINC, CDNC, JDNA etc ... ss a "Country Code Top Level Domain (ccTLD) Management Task Force" in each region. Each regional task force would include the current ccTLD managers and a government representative. * These Task Forces would be expected to report to the Sub-Committee through the WSIS process between 2003 and 2005. * Provide resources for civil society organisations, including women's organisations to enhance grassroots participation in the ICT policy processes. Marginalized groups * Special attention shall be given in the information society to traditionally marginalized groups, such as indigenous peoples, women, people with disabilities, older people, refugees, migrants and those who lack access to formal education and higher technical training. * Public investment in capacity building focused on the creation of locally produced, audience sensitive content that responds to local needs, and marginalized communities. * Online media workers should have the same contractual rights and protections as other media workers. * Establish global accounting standards for intangible assets, in order to make annual company reports more comparable and prevent fraudulent accounting practices. 7) Promotion of development-oriented ICT applications for all * Public participation in the information society shall be enabled through affordable and appropriate ICT applications allowing for local content creation, such as community media, non-profit media, and interactive Web applications. * The process of transformation into information societies requires the development and deployment of Open Source/Free Software as a means to improve productivity and quality of life in developing countries. * There is a need to prioritize and develop uses of ICTs for development e.g. health in relation to pandemic diseases, agriculture e.g. early warning systems and education. * Facilitate exchange mechanisms for volunteers to share experiences across sectors and projects related to plan of action of the Summit, e.g. bridging the digital divide. * ICT tools should be developed for e-government, with a priority to promoting greater civil participation in governance decision making. * To create an enabling environment, ICT policy processes must integrate gender analysis at all stages of their development, from the initial design to implementation, monitoring and evaluation. This requires analysis of the current status of women and men's participation in and use of ICT, including a comprehensive analysis of sex-disaggregated statistics and indicators and policy responses that target gender-based differences and inequalities. In addition, the policy process itself needs to be inclusive and consultative through the participation of stakeholders groups representative of the full spectrum of society, including gender advocates * Allocate adequate resources for policy development to integrate gender equality in ICT policies including funds for research and analysis that demonstrates the impact of ICT policies on gender equality as well as the human resource capacity to ensure that gender analysis is fully integrated in the ICT policy process. * Strengthen national machineries for the advancement of women, particularly through increased financial resources and technical expertise that can facilitate their advocacy role and collaborative action amongst government bodies * Develop gender-sensitive technical and regulatory instruments when addressing ICT policy issues such as universal access, regulatory frameworks, licensing, tariffing, spectrum allocation, infrastructure, ICT industry development and labour policies. * Develop, promote and support gender sensitive educational programmes and appropriate learning environments including e-learning to increase women's access to education. * Implementation of measures to ensure women's equal access to ICT education, training and literacy by: Sum Integrating ICT education in school curricula based on gender equality; Sum Realising girls' full participation in science and technology education; Sum Developing relevant distance ICT education and training programmes, especially for rural women and girls; * Governments and other actors, including trade unions, business and professional associations, and international organisations such as the ILO and UNCTAD, should: Sum Develop ICT-based information systems with relevant content for women to increase their economic opportunities and entrepreneurship skills, including information about national economic and trade policies and programmes; Sum Use ICT to increase women's economic literacy and their economic empowerment and participation; Sum Ensure that women gain access to new employment opportunities in the ICT area, including increasing women's access to ICT literacy and skills at all levels, and also ensure that women are not disproportionately disadvantaged by the working conditions and organisational climate common within the global ICT industry, such as "flexible" employment practices * Databases of best practices of donor and Civil society projects must be developed and linked. * A collaborative network of Open Source and Free Software technology tools for Civil society must be promoted. * National and regional online volunteering services should be established. 8) Cultural identity and linguistic diversity, local content and media development * Software companies and relevant national and international bodies should prioritise software development and transmission protocols in local languages. * Recognition and support will be given to media based in local communities, thus contributing to creating local content and preserving and developing cultural and linguistic diversity. * Recognition and support will be given to non profit media which give a voice to many marginalised or other ways underrepresented groups and thus represent a vital force to preserve and develop media diversity and media pluralism. * The development of policy, procedure and tools to ensure multi-lingualism in cyberspace, and in all other forms of media and communication systems, must respect the different language communities in the development of international standards. * There should be support for local creativity in any country, especially through promotion of local content contents to respond to local particularity and needs. * The creation and preservation of traditional and indigenous knowledge should be promoted. * There should be protection against unfair exploitation of indigenous knowledge and intellectual property * Develop, consistent with freedom of expression, regulatory mechanisms that promote balanced and diverse portrayals of women by the media and international communication systems and that promote increased participation by women and men in production and decision making. * Include content about women and gender issues in all official Government websites in addition to those websites that specifically cover gender equality issues. 9) Identifying and overcoming barriers to the achievement of the information society with a human perspective * International organisations, national and local governments should commit to giving online information on all public policies, public money uses, as well as benchmarking of the results of their policies. * Public service values in the Information Society should be encouraged, including genuine public service broadcasting. * Community and non-profit media should be promoted and developed as a major platform to enable public participation in the information society. They serve as essential factors of empowering marginalised communities, particularly youth, women, indigenous peoples, children and minority groups. * Community projects which can contribute to the democratic process, such as self-publication web sites on matters of local interest and affairs, should benefit from public support. * Support and encourage research programs to design, develop and adapt ICT infrastructure, tools and application that are responsive to the needs of the poor, especially non-literate women * Develop, promote and implement research programmes that permit ongoing and comprehensive analysis of the impact of ICT on gender equality and women's empowerment, particularly by development of appropriate indicators, conceptual frameworks and qualitative assessment methodologies and case studies. * Safeguarding environmental resources is central to achieving a healthy networked community for all. Southern countries are not the ICT garbage dump of the North: an active recycling policy should be established. Life cycle management in the production flow of ICT related goods must be promoted and implemented by the global ICT sector. Also, technologies should be mobilised in order to meet the specific of small islands under the endangered environment by hazards or global warming. * Tools should be developed to evaluate the social impact of ICTs and contribute to the eradication of poverty. This should be done with the involvement of all stakeholders, including the poor themselves, both in Northern and southern countries. * Develop reporting mechanisms to monitor progress towards gender equality in the ICT area _______________________________________________ Nettime-bold mailing list Nettime-bold@nettime.org http://amsterdam.nettime.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/nettime-bold